Essay · Tahj Holden

What Are We Doing Here?!

MAX Potential Basketball Club

Basketball Club

Insights

I Mean, Come On… What Are We Doing Here!?

I don’t mean that in the motivational-poster, halftime-speech kind of way. I mean it literally.

What are we doing to our kids in youth sports?

What kind of environment have we created—and why are we still allowing it to continue?

It’s a question I’ve been sitting with for a while. Not as an outsider or someone critiquing from a distance, but as someone who’s in it. Coaching. Leading. Learning. Getting things right, getting things wrong, and trying to make sense of it all while staying grounded in what actually helps kids grow.

Because when I look around, I see a lot of people chasing the wrong things.

Dreams and Nightmares

It starts with a dream—a kid with a ball, a court, and a belief. But somewhere along the way, that dream gets clouded by the noise. More rankings. More pressure. More chasing.

And what was supposed to be joy becomes something else. Something heavier. A quiet kind of nightmare—where the game feels more like a transaction than a passion.

We say we care about development—but how often do we let wins, status, or exposure come first?

Coaches clinging to wins instead of development. Trainers running packed sessions and making good money—but sometimes missing the mark when it comes to actually teaching the game: spacing, feel, timing, decision-making.

I get it. It’s easy to show quick improvement in a controlled setting. You can make a kid a better dribbler in one session if that’s all you’re working on. Put enough cones down, get enough reps, and yes—they’ll get better.

But here’s the issue: real basketball doesn’t happen in a vacuum.

When you train a skill out of context, you eventually have to drop it back into the chaos of the game—and that’s where it breaks down. It’s always messy when you take something clean and try to reintegrate it.

So we choose to start messy.

Because in that mess, players learn to adapt. They learn to see. They grow. It may take longer, but it lasts longer. Context matters. And context teaches.

Coming of Age

My basketball career started during the late 90s—right around the time AAU and travel basketball were really beginning to take off. That era was the spark that lit what has now become a full-blown industry. I was part of it. I played in those long weekends with 4–6 games, the hotel hallways full of sneakers and pizza boxes, the battle-tested tournaments that meant something.

But back then, it still felt grounded. You played to compete. There was pride in your team, your region, your coach. You didn’t bounce from program to program based on gear, social media, or promises.

Now it feels like everything’s on steroids.

More games. More tournaments. More teams. More “rankings.” And now, with NIL in the mix, the stakes are even higher. Families are thinking about money before development. Kids are under pressure to build a brand before they’ve built a skill set. Coaches are judged on 5th grade win-loss records. Trainers feel like they need to promise overnight results just to stay relevant.

The machine is louder now. More polished. More lucrative. But in a lot of ways, less real.

I remember being in 8th grade, riding my bike to the park to get shots up. I ran into an older player who had just committed to Rutgers—back when Rutgers basketball wasn’t exactly a powerhouse. I might’ve made a wisecrack about it, being the confident kid I was, and he clapped back quick:

“Where you going then?”

I told him UNC; my family’s from North Carolina so I was a Tar Heel fan, loosely.

He laughed and said,

“Man, your fat ass ain’t never going to Carolina.”

And you know what? He wasn’t wrong. At the time I was 6’5”, 250+ pounds. He had a point.

But what he didn’t know is I had the will. I had the fire. What I needed was development.

Years later, I went to Maryland, and during my senior year, we beat UNC by 15 at the Dean Dome and 40 at Cole Field House.

That’s the lesson: potential is noisy, but development is patient.

Sometimes you have to let your game bubble quietly. Stay down. Grow slow. Then one day you blow...

You can’t always predict where a kid will end up. You just have to build the right environment and give them time to grow. That’s what we’re doing now.

Old School, New School, Need to Learn Though…

I was born in 80's. Way back in the 1900's. Which means I straddle two worlds (and centuries).

I remember what it felt like to rewind the tape after breaking down a game, and I’ve also embraced platforms that clip film instantly. I’ve sat through chalk talks (with actual chalk) and now I coach through guided discovery. I’ve been coached the old school way, and I’ve spent the last few years unlearning some of those lessons while learning how to teach differently.

So I don’t knock tradition. I learned a lot through it. And I don’t blindly follow new trends either.

But I do believe this: the best path forward blends both.

We don’t need to erase everything that came before, but we do need to evolve. Because the old way might’ve worked for some of us, but it’s not built for the world kids are growing up in now.

This Can’t Be Life…

At Max Potential, we’re trying to build that bridge.

We coach using the Constraints-Led Approach (CLA), which means we train in context. We shape environments that force players to think, decide, adapt, and compete. We design training that looks, feels, and functions like the real game, not a stripped-down version of it.

We’re also committed to transformational coaching, not just building better basketball players, but better people. Athletes who are resilient. Adaptable. Joyful. Competitive in the right way.

But I’ll be real with you, it ain't easy. A lot of this feels like deprogramming. Maybe not so much the kids, because they’re naturally curious, creative, and adaptable when you give them permission, but the adults? The parents? The coaches? That’s where the work really is.

We’ve created a culture that’s rewarded results over learning, performance over process, and status over substance. So now, when we ask players to slow down, struggle, explore, or solve problems on their own… it feels foreign. Almost wrong. Like we’re under-coaching when in fact we’re doing the most valuable coaching of all.

We’re trying to help them learn how to learn again.

And I’ll be honest—I struggled with that this past season. Coaching at the varsity and junior varsity levels, I found myself constantly trying to help players understand that the process of becoming a better basketball player was the thing. That results would come, but only if we could commit to growth first. It wasn’t always easy. It didn’t always land. But it reminded me why this work is so necessary.

Because learning takes time. Development takes patience. And rewiring what we’ve been taught to value, whether you’re a player, parent, or coach, is hard. But if we want better outcomes, we have to start with a better process.

Our practices are intentionally chaotic. Our games are earned, not guaranteed. Our players make mistakes, get feedback, and try again. It’s not always pretty, but it’s purposeful.

Because we’re not building highlight tapes. We’re building learners.

I Ain’t No Perfect Man…

I’m not perfect. I’m not a guru. I’m not here to pretend I have all the answers.

I’m a practitioner. A dad. A coach who’s in the gym, watching film, tweaking sessions, and learning as I go.

But I do believe this work matters. And I do believe we can do better for our kids, our families, and our communities.

If you’re someone who feels like the current system isn’t working, but you haven’t found what comes next... I see you.

That’s why we’re building this. Not just for today’s players, but for the ones coming up behind them.

So again I ask:

What are we doing here?

Hopefully…

We’re building something better.